Jeffrey Aronheim
Contact us 720-200-5464

Resort Markets › Lake › Finger Lakes

Resort Market Guide · Finger Lakes, New York

Buying in the Finger Lakes

Eleven glacier-carved lakes, waterfall gorges and vineyards in upstate New York, from Canandaigua and Skaneateles to Watkins Glen. Short-term rentals collect New York sales tax, and towns set their own rules.

This guide covers what makes the area special, where people buy, the rental rules in plain English, the seasons and what's coming. When you're ready, we'll help you finance it the right way.

Photo: Canandaigua Lake and its hills by Brampton Cyclist, CC BY 2.0 (via Wikimedia Commons)

  • $351,506Canandaigua median sale price, three months to Oct 2026 (Redfin)
  • 11Finger Lakes, carved by glaciers (NY State Parks)
  • 19waterfalls in Watkins Glen State Park
  • 200 ftcliffs along the Watkins Glen gorge
  • Mar 2025NY sales tax began on short-term rental stays*
Map of the Finger Lakes region of New York showing Canandaigua, Watkins Glen, Skaneateles and Ithaca

Where it is

The Finger Lakes, upstate New York

  • Canandaigua sits at the north end of Canandaigua Lake, southeast of Rochester.
  • Watkins Glen is at the south end of Seneca Lake.
  • Skaneateles is to the east, near Syracuse; Ithaca is on Cayuga Lake.
Open in Google Maps

Drive times are approximate, in good conditions without traffic; check current conditions before you go. Map data © OpenStreetMap contributors.

*Rules change. Always verify with the town or county before you buy. Sources are listed at the bottom of this page.

Why people buy here

Why people buy in the Finger Lakes.

Wine country

Vineyards and tasting rooms line the hillsides above the lakes.

Lakeside villages

Canandaigua, Skaneateles, Geneva and Watkins Glen each have their own main streets.

Cottages to lake houses

Choose from lakefront cottages, village homes and hillside homes with lake views.

A great fit if you…

  • Want a lake house with a slower pace.
  • Like boating, wine tasting, hiking and small towns.
  • Are open to owner use or longer stays if the home doesn't qualify for short-term rental.

Photo gallery

See the Finger Lakes.

Photo credits (all via Wikimedia Commons, resized for web): Watkins Glen State Park by bobistraveling (CC BY 2.0) · Skaneateles by Kiran891 (CC BY-SA 4.0) · Seneca Lake vineyards by Tthaas (CC BY-SA 3.0) · Canandaigua Lake boathouses by VisitFingerLakes (CC BY-SA 3.0) · Taughannock Falls by Awinch1001 (CC0) · Canandaigua Lake (hero) by Brampton Cyclist (CC BY 2.0) · Skaneateles pier (closing photo) by Kiran891 (CC BY-SA 4.0)

Areas & typical prices

Where people buy in the Finger Lakes.

The Finger Lakes span many counties, towns and villages, and each sets its own rental rules. Confirm the rules where the home sits.

West

Canandaigua & Keuka

Lake towns closest to Rochester.

Central

Seneca Lake & Geneva

Wine trails and lakefront from Geneva to Watkins Glen.

East

Skaneateles & Owasco

Village life near Syracuse.

South

Cayuga Lake & Ithaca

Gorges, parks and a college town.

Approximate median sale prices

AreaProperty typeMedianPeriod & source
CanandaiguaAll homes$351,506Three months to Oct 2026; +9.8% year over year; median 8 days on market (Redfin) [1]

Redfin's figure covers the City of Canandaigua and combines condos, townhomes and single-family homes, so it moves with the mix of what sold. Lakefront homes aren't broken out and can be priced very differently. Medians aren't a valuation of any specific home. Ask a local agent for current comps.

Condos

Condos and townhomes in the Finger Lakes.

Condos and townhomes appear in some lake towns, often near marinas and village centers. For condos, lenders look at the building as well as the buyer, and starting that review early keeps things smooth. Our guide, Buying a resort condo: what lenders look at, explains how it works. It applies to condos only; townhomes aren't subject to condo review.

Short-term rental rules

What it takes to rent it out legally.

As of November 20, 2026. Verify with the town or county before you buy.

Since March 1, 2025, New York sales tax applies to short-term rental stays. Counties, towns and villages may add their own taxes and rules.

JurisdictionPermit & statusKey requirements
State of New York: sales taxState and local sales tax on short-term rental stays when the rate is more than $2 per unit per day.Effective March 1, 2025.
Booking services and operatorsBooking services like Airbnb register and collect the tax on the stays they handle; owners who rent directly register as sales tax vendors.Keep the booking service's certificate of collection.
Counties and localitiesLocalities may charge an added occupancy tax, administered locally.Check with the county where the home sits.
Towns, villages and HOAsNot summarized here.Many lake towns set their own rental permits or limits, so check early.

Details are from the NYS Department of Taxation and Finance (see Sources). Rules change, and this is a summary, not legal or tax advice.

Good to know about rentals here

  • Check the town. Many lake towns and villages set their own rental rules.
  • Ask about the shoreline. For lakefront, ask about docks, frontage and seasonal access.
  • Ask about water and septic. Many lake homes use wells, lake water or septic systems.
  • Plan for winter. Ask about snow removal, road access and heating.

Check before you buy: rules and taxes change and can differ by address and by association, so confirm the details for the exact home with the city or county.

Seasonality

How the year tends to play out.

We haven't published rental revenue or occupancy numbers for the Finger Lakes. Averages vary a lot by building and unit, so ask a local manager for real data on the specific home.

Winter

December to March

Quiet lakes and winter wine trails.

Spring

April to May

Waterfalls at full flow.

Summer

June to August

Boating and lake days.

Fall

September to November

Harvest season and fall color.

Season bars are a qualitative picture of relative demand, not measured occupancy. Your results depend on size, location, amenities, management and pricing.

What's coming

What's coming to the Finger Lakes.

Status as of November 20, 2026. Plans change, approvals are not guaranteed, and none of this is a prediction about prices. Ask us for the latest before you buy.

  • A boutique hotel in Skaneateles. Under construction The former Hilltop restaurant and bowling alley on Route 20 is becoming a complex with a 20-room boutique hotel and coffee shop, targeted to open in early December, with a restaurant to follow in spring.

Getting there & things to do

Upstate New York, between Rochester and Syracuse.

Getting there

  • By car: The New York State Thruway (I-90) runs across the north end of the lakes.
  • By air: Rochester, Syracuse and Ithaca have airports.
  • Around the lakes: Scenic routes and wine trails circle each lake.

Things to do

  • On the water: Boating, paddling and swimming.
  • Wine: Tasting rooms on Seneca, Cayuga and Keuka lakes.
  • Hiking: Watkins Glen and Taughannock gorges.
  • Town life: Canandaigua and Skaneateles villages.

How we help you buy here

The right loan for how you'll actually use it.

Resort purchases go sideways when the loan doesn't match the plan, or when the building doesn't fit the loan. We start with how you'll use the home, then structure the financing around it, before you fall in love with a listing.

Second-home loans

Built for a place you'll use yourself, with occasional rental allowed. These often come with better pricing than investment loans.

Investment-property loans

When renting is the main plan, this is the honest fit. We'll show you how rental income can count toward qualifying.

DSCR loans

Qualify based on the property's rental income rather than your personal tax returns. This is popular with business owners and investors who own several properties.

Condo review first

We look at the building's budget, reserves and insurance early, so a condo that won't work for a conventional loan shows up before you're under contract.

We also handle non-warrantable condos, jumbo loans, bank-statement loans for self-employed buyers, and land and construction financing. We lend nationally through CrossCountry Mortgage. 250+ five-star reviews and 2,000+ families helped.

FAQ

Common questions about buying in the Finger Lakes.

Can I rent my Finger Lakes home on Airbnb or Vrbo?

New York sales tax applies to short-term rental stays, usually collected by the booking service. Your county may add an occupancy tax, and many towns and villages have their own rental rules.

How many Finger Lakes are there?

New York State Parks counts 11 Finger Lakes, carved by glaciers. Popular second-home lakes include Canandaigua, Keuka, Seneca, Cayuga and Skaneateles.

What do lenders look at in a condo?

Lenders review the building as well as you: its reserves, insurance, ownership mix, litigation and rental activity. Many condos finance conventionally, and others work with a different program. Our condo guide explains how it works. It applies to condos only; townhomes aren't subject to condo review.

Should I use a second-home loan or an investment loan?

It depends on how you'll use the home. If it's mainly for you and your family, with occasional rentals, a second-home loan may fit. If renting is the main plan, an investment-property or DSCR loan is the right structure. We'll walk through it with you on a 15-minute call.

Talk to us about buying in the Finger Lakes.

Tell us how you plan to use the home and what you're looking at. We'll map the right loan, your rental-rule and condo questions, and a clear next step, usually in one 15-minute call.

Prefer to talk now? Call 720-200-5464.

Team Aronheim, The Resort Lending Experts. We lend nationally through CrossCountry Mortgage. This is not a commitment to lend. All loans are subject to credit approval. Market, rental and regulatory information is general education gathered from public sources, may change, and isn't legal, tax or investment advice.

×
Hold on!
Not sure where to start?
Let's build your custom plan today.
Schedule a Call
Call me now
720-200-5464
Schedule a Call