You found the cabin near the slopes or the condo on the beach, and the seller isn’t going to wait. But the rental, duplex or land you plan to sell hasn’t sold yet. A regular 1031 exchange has you sell first. A reverse 1031 exchange flips the order: you buy first and sell second, and still try to defer the tax.

It can work, but it is more complicated, more expensive and harder to finance than a regular exchange. This guide covers the plain-English version so you know what to ask before you sign a purchase contract.

Important: Team Aronheim does not provide tax or legal advice. Talk with your CPA or tax advisor before making decisions.

The short version

  • In a reverse exchange you buy the new property first, then sell the old one.
  • A third party, the exchange accommodation titleholder, holds title to one of the properties while the exchange is finished.
  • Under the IRS safe harbor you have 45 days to identify what you’ll sell and 180 days to finish.
  • It costs more and has more moving parts, and financing is specialized.
  • If you can sell first, a regular exchange is usually simpler.

Regular exchange vs. reverse exchange

In a regular (delayed) 1031 exchange, you sell your property first. A qualified intermediary holds the proceeds, you have 45 days to identify what you may buy, and 180 days to close on it.

In a reverse exchange, the order is flipped. You acquire the new property before the old one is sold, so someone else has to hold title to one of them in the meantime. That someone is the exchange accommodation titleholder, often called the EAT.

The same basic rules still apply. Both properties generally have to be held for investment or business use, so a second home you keep for your own getaways doesn’t qualify. See our guide on vacation home vs. investment property for how lenders view that line.

Why resort buyers consider a reverse exchange

  • The seller won’t wait. In a competitive resort market, the home you want may sell while your current property is still on the market.
  • Timing. You may want to close before a season starts, or before a price changes.
  • No pressure to sell cheap. You buy first, then take time to sell, within the safe harbor deadlines.

How a reverse exchange works

Most reverse exchanges follow the IRS safe harbor in Revenue Procedure 2000-37, called a qualified exchange accommodation arrangement. In plain English:

Day 0
The exchange accommodation titleholder takes title to the property, usually through a new single-member LLC it owns.

Within 5 business days
You and the titleholder sign a written agreement that says the titleholder holds the property for your benefit to facilitate an exchange.

Day 45
Your deadline to identify, in writing, the property you will sell.

Day 180
The titleholder must hand off the parked property by this date, and the combined parking time cannot exceed 180 days.

Once your old property is sold, the money goes to your qualified intermediary, and the titleholder transfers the new property to you. Weekends and holidays count, and these deadlines generally can’t be extended.

What the exchange accommodation titleholder does

The titleholder is a neutral party that holds legal title so the IRS can respect your transaction as an exchange. Under the safe harbor:

  • It cannot be you or a disqualified person, such as a related party. Your agent, attorney or accountant generally can’t fill the role.
  • It must be subject to federal income tax, and it is treated as the owner of the property for federal tax purposes while it holds title.
  • The safe harbor allows you to guarantee its debt, lend or advance it money, lease the property from it, and manage the property while it is parked.

Because the titleholder is treated as the owner during the parking period, how things like depreciation and income are reported during that time are questions for your tax advisor.

Which property gets parked?

Most reverse exchanges park the new property you are buying, because parking the property you are selling can cause trouble with your existing mortgage and starts the clock on that property. The other option, parking the property you’re selling, exists but is less common. Your intermediary can walk you through which fits your deal.

Cost and complexity

A reverse exchange has more pieces than a regular one. Expect:

  • An extra entity. A new single-member LLC usually holds title to the parked property.
  • More documents. Typically a written exchange accommodation agreement, an assignment of your purchase contract to the titleholder, a lease back to you, an environmental indemnity and loan or advance documents.
  • More fees. Titleholder and intermediary fees plus extra attorney time. We don’t quote ranges, so ask for written quotes up front.
  • Cash up front. The full purchase price has to be funded before the old property sells.
  • HOA and condo questions. Ask the association whether title in an LLC, or a transfer on the way to you, triggers approvals or fees. Resort associations differ.

Planning to buy before you sell? Let’s talk financing before you sign.

A 15-minute call is enough to map out your options and what to bring to your intermediary and tax advisor.

Book a 15-min call Apply Now

Financing a reverse exchange

Financing is usually the hardest part of a reverse exchange. Because the titleholder owns the property, you can’t simply apply for a standard mortgage in your own name on a property you don’t yet own, and most standard mortgage programs are designed for a borrower who will hold title at closing.

Reverse exchange financing is specialized, and it is handled through select lenders that are set up for the structure. We don’t finance reverse exchanges directly. If you’re considering one, we’re happy to talk through your options, and your qualified intermediary and tax advisor can help you find a lender experienced with the structure.

  • Your own funds. Some exchangers advance their own cash to the titleholder to buy the property. The safe harbor allows you to lend or advance funds to the titleholder.
  • A loan to the titleholder’s LLC. Where a specialized lender is involved, the LLC typically borrows and you guarantee. The loan has to be non-recourse to the titleholder and the LLC, and it needs a clause that allows the one-time transfer to you without triggering the due-on-sale provision.
  • Tell the lender early. Traditional lenders will usually not finance parked property, so bring any lender into the conversation about the structure before you apply, not after approval.

If you are thinking about borrowing against the property once the exchange is complete, ask your tax advisor first. How and when you borrow can affect the exchange.

What we do finance is the regular 1031 path, where you sell first and take title to the new property at closing. If you can sell first, call us and we can map out your options and your timeline before the 45-day clock starts.

When a regular 1031 exchange is better

  • You can sell first. If a buyer is lined up or your property will sell quickly, a regular exchange is simpler and cheaper.
  • Financing matters. In a regular exchange you take title to the new property at closing, so standard financing is generally available, and that is the path we finance.
  • You already own the property. The reverse safe harbor does not cover a property you owned before the arrangement started (Revenue Procedure 2004-51).
  • Your timeline is flexible. You don’t need the extra structure if the seller will wait.

Common mistakes to avoid

  • Signing a contract in your own name with no assignment right. The contract generally has to be assigned to the titleholder, so plan for that before you sign.
  • Hiring help too late. Line up your intermediary, titleholder and attorney before the contract, not after.
  • Missing the five-business-day agreement. The written agreement is part of the safe harbor.
  • Missing day 45. No identification, no exchange.
  • Waiting on financing. Line up funding for the structure weeks ahead, not days.
  • Buying a place for personal use. A true second home doesn’t qualify.
  • Skipping advice. Talk to your tax advisor before you contract.

Related guides

Quick answers

What is a reverse 1031 exchange?

In a reverse exchange you buy the new property first and sell the old one afterward. Because the tax rules want an exchange rather than a sale and a separate purchase, a third party called an exchange accommodation titleholder holds title to one of the properties until the exchange is finished. The IRS has a safe harbor, Revenue Procedure 2000-37, that many exchangers follow.

What does the exchange accommodation titleholder do?

The titleholder holds legal title, often through a new single-member LLC, so that you are not treated as owning both properties at once. It cannot be you or a disqualified person, such as your agent or a related party. You and the titleholder sign a written agreement within five business days of the titleholder taking title, and the titleholder is treated as the owner for federal tax purposes while it holds the property.

What are the deadlines in a reverse exchange?

Under the safe harbor, you must identify the property you will sell within 45 days after the titleholder takes title to the new property. The titleholder can hold the property for no more than 180 days, and the combined time the property you buy and the property you sell are held by the titleholder cannot exceed 180 days. These are firm, so build your timeline backward from day 180.

Can I get a mortgage for a reverse 1031 exchange?

It is harder than a regular purchase. Because the titleholder owns the property, you generally cannot apply for a standard mortgage in your own name. Reverse exchange financing is specialized and handled through select lenders. We don’t finance reverse exchanges directly, but we can talk through your options, and we do finance the regular 1031 path where you sell first. Raise financing with your intermediary and tax advisor before you sign the purchase contract.

Does a reverse exchange cost more than a regular 1031 exchange?

Usually yes. There is an extra entity, more legal documents, a titleholder fee, and you need the purchase funds up front. We don’t quote fee ranges here because they vary by provider and deal, so ask your intermediary and attorney for written quotes before you commit.

When is a regular 1031 exchange the better choice?

If you can sell your property first and still find a replacement within the 45- and 180-day windows, a regular exchange is simpler, cheaper and easier to finance, because you take title to the new property at closing. A reverse exchange makes more sense when you must close on the new property before you can sell. Also, the reverse safe harbor does not apply to a property you already own.

Ready to talk through your purchase?

Book a 15-min call Apply Now

This guide is for general education and is not tax or legal advice. 1031 exchange rules, including the reverse exchange safe harbor, are strict and depend on your situation. Please consult your tax advisor, attorney and a qualified intermediary or exchange accommodation titleholder before you buy or sell.

Sources: IRS Revenue Procedure 2000-37 (exchange accommodation arrangements) · IRS Revenue Procedure 2004-51 · IRS: Like-kind exchanges, real estate tax tips · IPX1031: Reverse exchange reference book · Exeter 1031: Getting started with a reverse exchange · Madison 1031: Clear communications with mortgage lenders in reverse exchanges

Hero image: illustration created for Team Aronheim.